Landlord ignores a leaking kitchen sink for 5 weeks while tenant's cabinet fills with mold and her utility bill climbs, resident threatens to hire a plumber herself and deduct it from rent: 'I know the law is on my side'

Author image for Inés Soubrie
Inés Soubrie • Writer and Editor
May 2, 2026 1:45 PM EDT

A leaking sink is not only an inconvenience, it's a legal violation.

There's a specific kind of powerlessness that comes with renting. You're paying for a place to live, on time, every month,  and somewhere along the way the person cashing your check decided that basic maintenance was optional. The sink leaks. The mold grows. The utility bill climbs. And when you finally say something, suddenly you're the problem.

Let's be clear: a landlord who ignores a leak for five weeks isn't "looking for a good plumber." They're banking on your patience running out before their negligence catches up with them.

Here's what's actually happening legally. In virtually every state, landlords are required by law to maintain habitable living conditions. That means working plumbing. That means no mold. That means a kitchen that functions like a kitchen and not a swamp. This isn't a favor they're doing you, it's a legal obligation that existed the moment you signed that lease. The tenant who sent a screenshot of local repair-and-deduct laws didn't threaten her landlord. She educated him. There's a difference.

Advertisement
  • 01
    Tired woman wearing black shorts and a white top it laying on the floor wing her back on the bed
    via Meg Aghamyan

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  •  

    The threat of eviction was a power move, not a legal reality. A landlord cannot evict a tenant for exercising documented legal rights, especially when there's a paper trail ,calls, texts, screenshots, showing they failed to act first. That paper trail is gold. Every text, every call log, every photo of that bucket sitting under the sink is evidence of negligence, and it matters enormously if this ever goes further.

    What she should do right now: send a formal written notice via email, not just text, stating the issue, the timeline, and a firm repair deadline. Document everything with photos and timestamps. Contact her local housing authority or tenant's rights organization, most of which offer free guidance specifically for situations like this. Many cities have hotlines. Many have inspectors who can formally cite a landlord for code violations, which creates a record that no lease clause can erase.

    The system isn't perfect. But it exists precisely for this. A landlord who threatens eviction the second a tenant mentions their legal rights is a landlord who knows they're wrong and is hoping intimidation works faster than accountability.

    It doesn't have to. Not this time.

  • 02
    I am absolutely losing my mind right now because of the pure audacity of my landlord. For the last five weeks I have had this steady leak under my kitchen sink that has slowly turned into a
    via NebuliteCorsair
  • 03
    swamp. I have called him four times and sent even more texts but he just keeps saying he is "looking for a plumber who isnt a ripoff" or some other nonsense. Meanwhile my
    via NebuliteCorsair
  • 04
    utility bill is climbing and the cabinet is starting to smell like mold.
    via NebuliteCorsair
  • 05
    A kitchen faucet.
    via topcools tee

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 06
    Yesterday I finally snapped and told him that if he doesnt have someone here by Friday I am just going to hire a guy myself and take the 200 bucks out of next months rent. I
    via NebuliteCorsair
  • 07
    even sent him a screenshot of the local tenant laws about "repair and deduct." This guy who hasnt replied to me in ten days suddenly calls me back within five minutes
    via NebuliteCorsair
  • 08
    screaming about how that is a violation of my lease and he will start the eviction process the day my rent comes up short.
    via NebuliteCorsair
  • 09
    He literally told me that if I "touch the plumbing" it is considered property damage.
    via NebuliteCorsair
  • 10
    Plumber wearing jeans is laying on the floor checking the kitchen faucet.
    via Curated Lifestyle

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 11
    The worst part is that I am stuck here. My credit isnt great and moving costs in this city are insane right now so I cant just pack up and leave like people always suggest. It feels like
    via NebuliteCorsair
  • 12
    he knows I have nowhere else to go so he can just let my apartment rot while he pockets my check every month. I am currently using
    via NebuliteCorsair
  • 13
    a literal bucket and emptying it twice a day just so I dont lose my security deposit to "water damage" that is his d fault to begin with. in
    via NebuliteCorsair
  • 14
    Sad woman sitting on the flor laying her back on her bed.
    via Meg Aghamyan

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 15
    How do I actually handle this leach without ending up on the street? I know the law is technically on my side but I cant afford a lawyer and he knows it.
    via NebuliteCorsair
  • 16
    Has anyone successfully forced a landlord to fix basic stuff without them retaliating like a psycho or is my only option to just keep living in a puddle until my lease is up?
    via NebuliteCorsair
  • 17
    A printed formal contacted on a desk.
    via Getty Images

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 18
    Mylar_Quill The audacity of some people. He can ignore a leak for weeks but finds his phone in seconds when the money is mentioned.
    via Mylar_Quill
  • 19
    Talon_4Vellum Record everything. Every text, every call, and take photos of that bucket and the mold starting to grow.
    via Talon_4Vellum
  • 20
    If he actually tries to evict you for exercising your legal right to repair and deduct, you will want all that evidence for the judge.
    via Talon_4Vellum
  • 21
    MythicCaravel Check if there is a local tenants union or a housing board in your city. Usually, just mentioning you are filing a formal complaint about habitability makes these leeches move a lot faster.
    via MythicCaravel
  • 22
    vea-fungus Well starting off with what state you live I. Would be a good start! There are probably free legal services in your county and you might have fair housing.
    via yea-fungus
  • 23
    MagicianEconomy5891 Call if available in your area, City inspectors or a person in health services. If black mold, it can k I you. It needs to be fixed ASAP along with othe repairs.
    via MagicianEconomy5891
  • 24
    Chrimaho Clue him in on taskrabbit and see which rate he's willing to pay.
    via Chrimaho
  • 25
    Dizzy_Emotion7381 Call the city and report him! They'll make him fix it because fines and fees.
    via Dizzy_Emotion7381
  • 26
    ruehiteu You landlord understands the leak is damaging their property?
    via ruehiteu

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

bad roommates reddit story Reddit roommates money entitled people
Scroll Down For The Next Article